Market Structure
- Regulated States
Utilities manage generation, transmission, and distribution. Consumers must buy energy from their designated utility.
- Deregulated States
Consumers can choose from multiple Retail Energy Providers (REPs) competing on price, contract terms, and green options. Utilities still manage infrastructure (wires, poles, meters).
Deregulated Electricity Markets Include:
- Texas (ERCOT – largest and most active deregulated market)
- New York
- Illinois
- Ohio
- Pennsylvania
- New Jersey
- Maryland
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- Washington D.C.
- Maine
- New Hampshire
- Massachusetts
- Michigan (partial)
Note: Natural gas is also deregulated in some states.
Key Players
- Utilities: Deliver Power and Maintain Infrastructure
Utilities are the backbone of the U.S. energy system. They are responsible for the transmission and distribution of electricity and gas to homes and businesses. This includes managing the physical infrastructure—such as power lines, substations, transformers, and gas pipelines—that ensures energy is safely and reliably delivered to end users.
Unlike energy retailers in deregulated markets, utilities do not compete for customers. They operate as regional monopolies regulated by state public utility commissions, and customers are assigned a utility based on their geographic location.
Examples of Major U.S. Utilities:
- Con Edison – Serves much of New York City and Westchester County
- PG&E (Pacific Gas & Electric) – Covers large parts of Northern and Central California
- Oncor – The largest utility in Texas, operating within the ERCOT grid
Utilities also handle:
- Metering and outage response
- Grid maintenance and upgrades
- Billing (in regulated markets or for delivery charges in deregulated ones)
- Retail Energy Providers (REPs): Power Sellers in Deregulated Markets
In deregulated energy markets across the U.S., Retail Energy Providers (REPs) are licensed companies that sell electricity or natural gas directly to customers. Unlike utilities that manage infrastructure and delivery, REPs purchase energy on the wholesale market and offer retail plans with varying pricing models, contract terms, and value-added services.
They compete on:
- Pricing (fixed, variable, time-of-use)
- Renewable energy options
- Customer incentives and loyalty programs
- Contract length and early exit fees
- Online account tools and customer support
Consumers still receive energy through their local utility, but the REP is who they pay for supply in deregulated markets.
Top REPs by Deregulated State
Texas (ERCOT)
- Reliant Energy
- TXU Energy
- Direct Energy
- Gexa Energy
- Pulse Power
- Constellation
- Frontier Utilities
- Just Energy
- Rhythm Energy
- Cirro Energy
- Payless Power
- Amigo Energy
- Chariot Energy
- Discount Power
New York
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Ambit Energy
- Just Energy
- Green Mountain Energy
- Major Energy
- Clearview Energy
- Energy Harbor
- Public Power
- Verde Energy
- Think Energy
Illinois
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Spark Energy
- Clearview Energy
- MC Squared Energy
- AEP Energy
- Ambit Energy
- XOOM Energy
Pennsylvania
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Energy Harbor
- NRG Home
- Inspire Energy
- Just Energy
- Shipley Energy
- Public Power
- Vista Energy
- Tomorrow Energy
Ohio
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- AEP Energy
- Energy Harbor
- IGS Energy
- FirstEnergy Solutions
- XOOM Energy
- CleanChoice Energy
- Dynegy
New Jersey
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Energy Harbor
- Green Mountain Energy
- Just Energy
- Inspire Energy
- Palmco Energy
Maryland
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Tomorrow Energy
- Clearview Energy
- SmartEnergy
- CleanChoice Energy
- Energy Harbor
Connecticut
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Verde Energy
- Clearview Energy
- Public Power
- XOOM Energy
Massachusetts
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- CleanChoice Energy
- Public Power
- Clearview Energy
- Think Energy
New Hampshire
- ENH Power
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- XOOM Energy
- SmartEnergy
Maine
- Constellation
- Electricity Maine
- Clearview Energy
Delaware
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- Liberty Power
Washington, D.C.
- Constellation
- Direct Energy
- CleanChoice Energy
- ISOs and RTOs: The Backbone of Regional Grid Management
Independent System Operators (ISOs) and Regional Transmission Organizations (RTOs) are non-profit entities responsible for coordinating, controlling, and monitoring the operation of the electrical power system across large geographic areas in the U.S. They ensure that electricity supply and demand are balanced in real time and manage access to the wholesale electricity markets.
While they do not own generation or transmission assets, ISOs and RTOs provide a neutral, transparent platform for market participants—including power generators, utilities, and retail energy providers—to buy and sell electricity.
Their core responsibilities include:
- Grid Reliability: Maintaining continuous power supply and stability
- Market Operations: Running day-ahead and real-time electricity markets
- Transmission Planning: Ensuring long-term system capacity and reliability
- Fair Access: Providing non-discriminatory access to the transmission grid
- Integration of Renewables: Supporting clean energy integration and demand response
Major ISOs/RTOs in the U.S.
- ERCOT (Electric Reliability Council of Texas)
- Operates the grid and wholesale market in most of Texas
- Independent from federal regulation (FERC)
- Highly deregulated and competitive
- Known for innovative retail energy models
- PJM Interconnection
- Serves parts of 13 states and D.C., including Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Illinois
- One of the largest and most complex RTOs
- Runs robust day-ahead and real-time energy markets
- Integrates multiple fuel types and demand response
- CAISO (California Independent System Operator)
- Covers 80% of California and part of Nevada
- Focused heavily on integrating renewable energy (solar, wind)
- Plays a key role in managing supply-demand fluctuations due to variable generation
- NYISO (New York ISO)
- Manages the New York power grid and wholesale markets
- Oversees energy pricing, demand forecasts, and renewable integration
- MISO (Midcontinent ISO)
- Covers parts of 15 states and Manitoba, Canada
- Handles a diverse energy mix including wind, coal, nuclear, and gas
- ISO-NE (ISO New England)
- Covers six New England states
- Balances system reliability with clean energy transition
- SPP (Southwest Power Pool)
- Manages the grid for 14 states in the central U.S.
- Operates wholesale electricity markets and transmission planning
Why it pays to compare
- Consumer Choice: In deregulated states, customers can shop for cheaper rates, fixed or variable plans, and renewable energy options.
- Growing Competition: Over hundreds of REPs operate nationally, especially in Texas, New York, and the Midwest.
- Digital Opportunity: Many consumers now compare and switch energy providers online, driving demand for energy comparison platforms and AI-driven solutions.